• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Scott McKelvey Copywriting & Marketing

I write marketing content that explains what you do, and the value of what you do, in a way that matters to your ideal client.

  • ABOUT
  • SERVICES
  • PORTFOLIO
  • REVIEWS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

Scott McKelvey / March 11, 2014

When Social Media Automation Makes You Look Like an Idiot

When Social Media Automation Makes You Look Like an Idiot

Social media automation can be a valuable, time-saving tool. But it shouldn’t make you numb to what’s happening in the world in real-time.

Would you paint the outside of your house in the pouring rain just because you put it on your schedule to paint on a certain day?

There are times when nobody will care about any kind of business-related social media post. It can be a major turn off or make you and your company the punch line of a joke.

And you can always tell who’s posting live and who scheduled their posts in advance.

Many of these events can be easily factored into your posting schedule with a little planning. However, unexpected events require you to stay on top of social media automation and pull the plug when appropriate.

Remember, when you post on social media, you’re a human addressing other humans, whether you post as yourself or a company.

Some events may have no impact on a certain percentage of your connections. I get that. But do you really want to risk turning off, offending or seeming insensitive to a large number of connections who are affected?

Regardless of the situation, you can’t just leave automation in cruise control. The potential damage to your reputation just isn’t worth it.

And you’ll look like an idiot.

Shut off social media automation during major televised events. For example:

Scheduling posts during awards shows like the Oscars, the Grammys or the Golden Globes is pretty much a waste of time.

I was hesitant to include awards shows until I read the eMarketer article that said more than nine in 10 women with access to the internet planned to watch last week’s Oscars broadcast.

Even more startling was that 97 percent of these women planned to use social media while watching the show.

Social Media Automation - Ellen SelfieEllen’s selfie shut down Twitter. Your infographic about the history of social media will not.

People are very active on social media during the Super Bowl, but they’re interested in hearing what people think about the commercials, not what you think about Google’s latest algorithms.

Prime time presidential speeches and debates give blowhards and know-it-alls an excuse to share their political rants on social media. Others comment on a politician’s hair or whether or not they wore an American flag pin.

Don’t let social media automation share your five tips for writing a better press release during major political events on TV. Nobody cares. At least not during this event.

And it makes you look like an idiot.

Shut off social media automation during major holidays. For example:

On Christmas and Thanksgiving, people are spreading good cheer, perhaps annoyingly so. They’re sharing photos of kids with friends and family. They’re trash-talking about the football or basketball games being played that day.

They’re sharing photos of the turkey. Again, perhaps annoyingly so. But that’s how people use social media during those holidays.

On New Year’s Eve, people are commenting on musical performances, what Kathy Griffin just said to Anderson Cooper, and how long people are forced to wait to go to the bathroom in Times Square. Your podcast about marketing trends for the following year will likely fall on deaf ears.

Yes, I’ve seen links to business-related articles on my Twitter and Facebook feeds on Christmas.

Just stop it. Please.

Also, consider shutting down social media automation, or at least be extremely careful about what you post, during solemn holidays like Veteran’s Day or Memorial Day. This is when people are thanking veterans for their service and remembering those who gave their lives so you have the freedom to post on social media.

Shut off social media automation during major weather events. For example:

Blizzards. Hurricanes. Tropical storms. Tsunamis. Earthquakes. An article about developing the perfect business plan.

Which one of these is not like the other?

When the lives of real people are being affected and possibly turned upside down, people turn to social media to watch events unfold and stay informed. They want to know their loved ones are okay. They want to be comforted and find out how they can help.

It’s not necessary to shut down social media automation every time we get a dusting of snow, but it’s a good idea to put automation on hold when a weather event is dominating news coverage.

Shut off social media automation during tragedies. For example:

This is the biggest danger of social media automation – or not staying on top of automation.

There’s a school shooting. Bombs go off during a major sporting event. Someone is released from 10 years of hellacious captivity that would turn any decent person’s stomach. Protestors are being gunned down in the streets by oppressive government forces.

And while people are commenting about a tragedy like this, out pops a Tweet or Facebook post that promotes a client success story.

Enough said.

By all means, use social media automation if it saves you time and enables you to focus more on strategic business tasks. Just don’t forget the power of the human element, or you’ll look like – well, you know…

Share this article:

Share on LinkedIn Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Email

Filed Under: Observations & Commentary

Scott McKelvey

Content writer. Marketing consultant. Storyteller. Communicator. Interviewer. Listener. Information sponge. Simplifier of the complex. Husband. Dad to two girls. Homework checker. Soccer coach. Not necessarily in that order.

Subscribe for the Win

Receive blog articles with insights, highlights, lowlights, and commentary about content writing and marketing.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. David Walter says

    September 17, 2014 at 4:42 am

    Nice article Scott. I agree with your comments about non-human like posts being annoying, and also believe social media automation for a business page can help keep the page moving depending on topic. Of course unpredictable events and times exist and should be taken into account. Great post about a topic being talked about more and more – Social Media Automation. Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
    • Scott McKelvey says

      September 17, 2014 at 9:35 am

      Thanks, David. Automation is a valuable tool, but it should never replace human emotion and common sense.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe for the Win

Receive blog articles with insights, highlights, lowlights, and commentary about content writing and marketing.

Recent Blog Articles

  • Someone Subscribed to My Blog When an Article I Wrote in 2014 Showed Up on Google. Here’s Why It Matters.
  • What Marketers Can Learn from Mrs. Parker’s Storytelling Advice to Ralphie
  • Research: Thought Leadership Got Crowded but Still Delivers Serious Value
  • Marketing Observations from My Summer Vacation, 2022 Edition
  • It’s All About Creating Moments of Human Connection

Footer

Contact

PO Box 160
Florence, NJ 08518
908-907-0031
info@ScottMcKelvey.com

Search

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

© Scott McKelvey Consulting, LLC. All Rights Reserved.